White House Prepares Legal Fight Over Congressional Probes
The administration is asserting executive privilege to shield private advisers and companies from Democratic oversight investigations.
By Nathan Reed ·

Washington, D.C. The Trump administration has begun asserting executive privilege to protect private advisers and outside companies from congressional subpoenas, setting the stage for a legal clash with the Democratic-controlled Congress. White House counsel Will Scharf told the incoming House Oversight Committee chairman last week that the administration would not be cowed by unlawful process. He wrote that the president would fight to maintain the independent functioning of the executive branch.
Democratic committee leaders have already sent request letters seeking information on the Trump family’s ties to the crypto industry and the administration’s pressure on law firms. Sources say private outreach began before the election. At least one organization targeted by an executive order crackdown last year turned over records to Democrats within 48 hours of the election, ending months of stonewalling.
The administration is extending privilege claims to individuals who do not work in the government. A Justice Department memo argues that shielding private advisers allows the president to receive candid advice. The memo states that revealing the identity of those consulted could chill future deliberations. This approach mirrors an ongoing lawsuit involving the American Bar Association and Trump’s private attorney, Boris Epshteyn.
The legal strategy relies on precedent from the 2020 Supreme Court case involving the accounting firm Mazars. In that case, the court rejected blanket presidential immunity but required subpoenas to connect to a clear legislative purpose. Trump’s legal team used that litigation to delay oversight for more than a year. Lawyers believe the administration may use similar delay tactics this time, aiming to exhaust the 18-month window before the 2028 campaign begins.
Companies are preparing for the conflict by setting aside documents they believe will be responsive to subpoenas. James Bair, head of congressional investigations at Crowell & Moring, said receiving a subpoena creates a public messaging challenge for executives. He noted that many companies assume wrongdoing when served with such orders. Legal advisers are now working to negotiate deals that keep clients out of the news.
The administration is also testing these claims in a lawsuit over the Kennedy Center. Democratic Rep. Joyce Beatty of Ohio is challenging plans to close the center for renovations and rename it after the president. Beatty argues that privilege should not apply because Trump’s role as board chairman is separate from his presidential duties. The administration contends that restricting privilege to executive branch officials would prevent the president from relying on outside sources.
Justice Department officials have floated criminal probes into lawmakers investigating the administration. A letter from Aaron Reitz, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas, signaled to potential witnesses that the DOJ might intervene. Mary Dohrmann, an attorney for former FBI agents, warned that these tactics could chill individuals from sharing facts with Congress. The agents’ cases were thrown out by a judge this month.
More Politics · Charlotte news · Report a business · Got a Story?






