AdvertiseDonate
Monday, November 16, 2026Local news for Mecklenburg County, North Carolina.
Mecklenburg Tribune · 6047 Tyvola Glen Circle, Charlotte, NC 28217

California rejects one-time billionaire tax as Democrats eye federal wealth changes

Prof. Ray Madoff of Boston College says the Supreme Court blocks federal wealth taxes, but Congress can fix the income tax code instead.

By Yasmin Farouk ·

Illustration for: California rejects one-time billionaire tax as Democrats eye federal wealth changes
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

California voters rejected a one-time tax on billionaires earlier this month. The loss leaves a gap in a political movement to tax the ultra wealthy just as Democrats prepare to regain power in Congress in 2027.

Ray Madoff, a tax law professor at Boston College, said the California ballot measure was expected to fail. He cited opposition from billionaires who spent heavily against the measure and from Democratic leaders who feared it would hurt the state's economic growth.

The current U.S. tax system was designed to place the heaviest burden on the wealthiest Americans. Madoff argues the system has evolved so that the richest people can avoid taxes entirely. He notes that the federal government collects roughly $5 trillion in tax revenue annually while spending about $7 trillion, creating a $2 trillion deficit.

The richest 1% of Americans hold $60 trillion in wealth. Madoff points out that a leaked tax return showed Jeff Bezos and other top earners paid no income tax for several years. He distinguishes between high income earners, such as doctors and lawyers, who pay most income taxes, and the wealthy, who avoid taxes by avoiding reportable income.

States face a unique hurdle in taxing wealth because residents can simply move to a different state. Madoff says the federal government faces an even steeper challenge. He believes the current U.S. Supreme Court would likely rule a federal wealth tax unconstitutional, making a direct tax on net worth legally difficult to implement.

Madoff suggests Congress should focus on broadening the income tax base instead. He proposes treating investment gains and inheritances the same way the tax code treats wages. This approach would raise revenue without requiring a new constitutional amendment or a direct tax on net worth.

The estate tax was intended to act as a sweep-up tax for wealth. Over the past 36 years, however, the estate and gift tax has lost effectiveness. In 2025, when the top 1% owned more than $50 trillion, the estate and gift tax generated only $28 billion in revenue.

Madoff argues that current rules allow large gifts and inheritances to pass without income tax reporting. He says fixing the income tax code to capture these transfers could help close the federal deficit and lower tax rates for other Americans.

More Politics · Charlotte news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Mecklenburg Tribune in your inboxLocal news for Mecklenburg County, North Carolina. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Mecklenburg Tribune in your inboxLocal news for Mecklenburg County, North Carolina. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.